5 Comments

Haven't had a chance to listen to the show yet, so forgive me if you've covered this. One thing that has always bothered me about the simulation hypothesis is that many of its advocates seem to discount the significance of the natural world, i.e., base reality. Simulation theory implies that mistakes can be fixed by pushing a reset button, but it it as simple as that? Can we get a reset on the recent elections, and also the Southern CA fires?

Expand full comment

Thanks for the comment!

In the episode, we briefly touched upon the concept of resets and complexity. One of the intriguing aspects of the Simulation Hypothesis is the possibility of resetting events or finding cheat codes to skip ahead. However, this idea becomes problematic when we consider that an outcome we dislike (like my football team losing) may bring immense joy to others.

We’ll definitely make sure to address this in the upcoming mini-episode.

Expand full comment

There is also a philosophical disagreement between naturalists who view the "real" world almost with a kind of reverence, and those mathematicians who assert that reality can be fully expressed in numerical terms. I'd like to be a fly on the wall when bigger brains hash this out!

Expand full comment

Haha, right? Imagine the debates! On one side, you’ve got naturalists worshiping at the altar of dirt and rocks like, “Look at this glorious tree! Touch grass! Reality is sacred!” Meanwhile, the mathematicians are whipping out equations like Neo in The Matrix, shouting, “That tree is just pi, e, c, and I!” Unraveling the “realists” with elegant proofs and philosophers retorting, “But you can’t smell a formula, can you!?”

Throw in a few biologist (I'd join in) and quantum physicists for spice, and you’ve got the nerdiest cage match of all time.

Expand full comment

"nerdiest cage match of all time"... you do have a way with words, haha!

As to whether reality is fundamentally mathematical... if it isn't, then what IS it??? Personally, I'm not comforted with the idea of kooky metaphysicians tap dancing on my skull. We need a new math?

Expand full comment